Concerns Arise Over Lawyer’s Push to Revoke Polio Vaccine Approval
Alarm bells rang among public health advocates, members of Congress, and various detractors following a report by The New York Times on Friday. The article detailed how a lawyer aiding Robert F. Kennedy Jr. in vetting candidates for the upcoming Trump administration sought to persuade U.S. regulators to rescind the approval of the polio vaccine in 2022.
“America has been at the forefront of the global effort to eliminate polio, which is on the brink of becoming only the second disease to be eradicated worldwide after smallpox,” stated Liza Barrie, director of global vaccines access at Public Citizen. “Any attempt to compromise polio vaccination initiatives threatens to undo decades of progress and dismantle one of the most significant public health triumphs ever achieved.”
Public Citizen is one of several organizations voicing opposition to President-elect Donald Trump’s decision to nominate Kennedy to lead the Department of Health and Human Services. The organization’s co-president, Robert Weissman, expressed concern, stating, “He shouldn’t even be allowed to step foot in the building, much less oversee the nation’s public health agency.”
Although Kennedy’s appointment is pending Senate approval, he is already consulting with potential candidates for senior health positions. He is being assisted by Aaron Siri, an attorney who also represented RFK Jr. in his presidential campaign, according to the Times. Siri is known for representing the Informed Consent Action Network (ICAN) in its petitions to the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) to “withdraw or suspend approval of vaccines for diseases like polio and hepatitis B.”
The newspaper reported:
“Aaron Siri is also advocating on behalf of ICAN, urging the FDA to ‘pause distribution’ of 13 additional vaccines, including those for tetanus, diphtheria, polio, and hepatitis A, until manufacturers disclose more information about aluminum, a component linked with a slight increase in asthma cases,” Siri declined an interview but mentioned that his petitions were filed on behalf of his clients. Katie Miller, a spokesperson for Kennedy, stated that while Siri advises Kennedy, he has not discussed these petitions with any of the health nominees. She further mentioned, “Kennedy has consistently advocated for transparency in vaccines and supports giving individuals a choice.”
Following the article’s release, Siri criticized it as a “typical NYT hit piece evidently authored by those lacking fundamental reading and reasoning skills,” and responded extensively on social media. He argued that “ICAN’s petition to the FDA seeks the revocation of a specific polio vaccine, IPOL, solely for infants and children and only until a proper trial is conducted, because IPOL was licensed in 1990 by Sanofi based on pediatric trials that, according to the FDA, only reviewed safety for three days post-injection.”
The Times highlighted that experts deem placebo-controlled trials that would deprive some children of polio vaccinations unethical because “you’re replacing a theoretical risk with a real one,” explained Dr. Paul A. Offit, a vaccine expert at the Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia. “The genuine risks are the diseases themselves.”
Ayman Chit, the head of vaccines for North America at Sanofi, informed the newspaper that the vaccine’s development started in 1977, over 280 million people globally have been vaccinated, and more than 300 studies have been conducted, some with follow-up periods of up to six months.
As Trump prepares to return to office in less than six weeks, his recent statements on vaccines have been ambiguous.
During a Time “Person of the Year” interview released Thursday, when asked about Kennedy’s controversial stance on vaccines, the president-elect remarked, “We’re going to conduct very rigorous testing,” and mentioned that some vaccines might be restricted “if I deem them hazardous.”
Trump expressed to NBC News last weekend, “Look, I’m not anti-vaccine. The polio vaccine is fantastic. Convincing me to eliminate it would be a tough sell. I believe certain vaccines are remarkable. However, some might not be, and we need to identify those.”
These comments, similar to the Friday report in the Times, drew widespread concern. Joyce White Vance, a law professor at the University of Alabama and columnist for MSNBC, described the report as “absolutely terrifying.”
The sentiment was echoed across the media, with HuffPost senior front page editor Philip Lewis stating, “This is just so dangerous and ridiculous,” while Mehdi Hasan, founder of Zeteo, exclaimed, “We are so—and I use this word carefully—screwed.”
Ryan Cooper, managing editor at The American Prospect, cautioned, “They want your children dead.”
Musician and author Mikel Jollett also expressed concern, saying, “So if you’re wondering if Donald Trump is trying to harm your children, yes, he is.”
Critics have modified Trump’s campaign slogan to “Make Polio Great Again.”
In response, U.S. Senator Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) posted a video on social media:
Without directly naming anyone, Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.), who survived polio, released a lengthy statement on Friday. “The polio vaccine has saved millions of lives and promises to eradicate a dreadful disease. Actions that weaken public trust in established remedies are not only misinformed—they’re perilous,” he stated. “Anyone seeking Senate approval to join the incoming administration should avoid even the semblance of association with such actions.”
Similar Posts
- Trump Directs Halt on Health Agency Advisories, Scientific Publications!
- Shocking Pick: Trump Nominates Dr. Oz to Head Medicare!
- Doctor Slams LA Times for Twisting His RFK Jr. Op-Ed: ‘Pretty Sh*tty’
- Trump Administration’s Brutal Overhaul Decimates Federal Health Agencies!
- Bobby Kennedy Jr. Reignites Eugenics Debate at Health and Human Services!
An economic reporter, Dax Everly breaks down financial trends and their impact on Americans’ daily lives.