Bobby Kennedy Jr. Reignites Eugenics Debate at Health and Human Services!

RFK Jr.’s Policies Echo Disturbing Historical Precedents

The ghost of Charles Fremont Dight seems to haunt the controversial initiatives of Bobby Kennedy, Jr. Dight, a medical professor at the University of Minnesota, was notorious for his desire to cleanse society of what he deemed its undesirable elements. Living part of his life in a treehouse, Dight penned works like “Increase of the Unfit, A Social Menace,” advocating for societal control over reproduction. He supported stringent immigration policies to bar “unfit” foreigners, explicitly excluding those of Anglo-Saxon descent, from entering the U.S. In 1933, Dight even sent a letter to Adolf Hitler, commending the dictator’s efforts to eradicate mental deficiencies.

In the early 20th century, eugenics was considered a legitimate branch of science, promoting restrictive marriage statutes, sequestering the “unfit” in specialized institutions, and mandatory sterilization to prevent societal burdens. This affected immigrants with poor English skills, individuals with learning disabilities or Down syndrome, and many others who were judged in eugenics courts and possibly isolated or sterilized.

A Modern Registry Echoing Past Discriminations

Bobby Kennedy, Jr., now leading the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), has introduced policies that alarmingly mirror those of past eugenicists. His plans include identifying and marginalizing the disadvantaged, fueling anti-immigrant and racist ideologies, and endorsing unscientific theories. Kennedy is pushing for a registry of individuals with autism, directing the National Institutes of Health (NIH) and the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) to develop a comprehensive data platform. This platform would integrate claims data, electronic health records, and information from consumer devices to study autism spectrum disorders. This initiative, potentially breaching federal privacy and security regulations, has been met with resistance, such as Illinois Governor JB Pritzker’s executive order preventing the federal collection of these data to safeguard the privacy and dignity of state residents.

Kennedy’s proposed registry risks stigmatizing individuals, particularly the youth, reminiscent of how eugenics proponents labeled the “feeble-minded.”

The HHS database, much like historical eugenics records, is expected to be subjective and based on superficial assessments. The Eugenics Record Office (ERO) in Cold Spring Harbor, New York, once collected and categorized Americans based on cursory observations, leading to the sterilization of 80,000 individuals believed to have hereditary defects.

Racial Prejudices and Unscientific Beliefs at HHS

Kennedy shares peculiarities and racial biases with historic eugenicists. His fascination with studying animal skulls, like his cutting up a whale skull found near the Kennedy Compound and transporting it, dripping with “whale juice,” reveals an odd link to past craniologists like Samuel Morton. Morton’s works positioned Native Americans and African Americans at the bottom of an intelligence hierarchy, justifying severe mistreatment.

Kennedy has perpetuated outdated racial theories, suggesting that African Americans have distinct medical characteristics and should therefore receive different medical treatments, such as an altered vaccine schedule based on a supposed stronger immune response to certain antigens.

Moreover, echoing the eugenics movement’s support for restrictive immigration laws, Kennedy’s role aligns with broader political stances that favor certain immigrant groups over others, reflecting historical prejudices that deemed some races superior.

The Flawed Science Behind Vaccine Fears

The foundation of Kennedy’s autism registry is the debunked theory that vaccines cause autism, originating from a discredited 1998 study by Andrew Wakefield. Despite substantial evidence refuting this claim, Kennedy continues to promote this false link, misrepresenting data to support his stance.

Public Health Risks from Misguided Policies

Kennedy’s propagation of pseudoscience threatens public health, potentially fueling outbreaks of preventable diseases due to vaccine hesitancy. His opposition to established health measures, like pasteurization and water fluoridation, underscores a broader disdain for scientific consensus and public health protocols.

In a broader context, Kennedy’s actions and the current political climate reflect a troubling resurgence of discredited scientific ideas, emphasizing innate qualities over empirical evidence, and potentially leading to policies that discriminate and harm rather than help.

As the saying goes, history may not repeat itself, but it often rhymes. In the case of Bobby Kennedy Jr.’s tenure at HHS, the echoes of a discredited past are loud and clear.

In a twist of irony, as we witness these developments, we’re reminded of Donald Trump’s preference for “the best people,” a sentiment that now rings with a historical echo of its own.